After a clue package including a plushy monster toy, joker cards and a reference to his career in film and television, Rock Lobster took to the stage with his take on “SOS.” Once his interesting, jovial performance was complete, Drag Race star Shangela emerged with Rock Lobster’s final clue: a bedazzled gavel.

Following the studio audience vote, Rock Lobster was eliminated and unmasked as comedian and America’s Got Talent judge Howie Mandel.

With the crustacean sent packing, Medusa and Night Owl were left to compete in the Battle Royale set to, fittingly, “The Winner Takes it All.”

For the second consecutive week, Medusa emerged victorious, leaving Night Owl to be revealed as ’80s pop icon Debbie Gibson.