And that’s when Paul appeared, noting, “Well, I do think it could get a little bit better.” 

How so? Well, fans got their answer when Meryl popped up from behind a couch. Selena captioned the video, “I could cry, season 3 is coming!”

And we could cry, too, with this dream cast line-up.

The first two season of Only Murders In The Building are available to stream on Hulu.